The Showcase Cup: When Short Prices Meet Soft Questions
Iron Man is short in the market, and I understand why. Stirling Osland's gelding won at Eagle Farm twelve days ago over this trip, and he's a proven performer on soft ground with three wins from fourteen starts on rain-affected surfaces. But here's what I don't love: he's first-up into a Benchmark 98 assignment carrying 63kg, and the pace scenario is dire. With no clear leaders, this becomes a tactical crawl, and Mikayla Weir will need to manufacture speed from barrier three or risk being stuck in a muddling tempo that doesn't suit his pattern. His last-start Eagle Farm win came from midfield with a strong tempo to run at. He won't get that luxury here.
Voracious is the runner I want at longer odds. Mack Griffith's gelding won at Tamworth seventeen days ago over 1600m, then ran third at Walcha before that. He's a Maurice gelding who has won seven from twenty-one, four of those wins at 1400m, and he handles soft tracks with two wins from five attempts. The concern is his record on genuinely testing ground, where he's less effective, but this is only a Soft 8 and he's proven at this level. Kody Nestor takes 2kg off, bringing him to 60kg, and from barrier eighteen he can settle wherever he likes in a race with no pressure. If they crawl, he's going to be storming home.
Hibiki Harmony is short as the market favourite, and I'm not convinced. Brett & Georgie Cavanough's mare ran second to Voracious at Tamworth seventeen days ago, beaten less than half a length, yet she's somehow shorter in betting here despite carrying the same weight and meeting him on identical terms. She's a consistent mare with five wins from twenty-two starts, but she's never won beyond 1400m and she's drawn barrier four in a race with no speed. Braith Nock's 3kg claim brings her to 55kg, which is a significant advantage, but I'd rather be on the horse that beat her last start at better odds.
So You Are returns from a 124-day spell after failing in two Melbourne Cups at Flemington and Moonee Valley. Before that, he ran a gutsy second in the Brisbane Cup at Eagle Farm over 2400m, beaten a nose, and won a Doomben 2200m Benchmark 78 by two and a half lengths. He's a genuine stayer by So You Think, but he's having his first run in four months, drawn the outside barrier, and dropping back to 1400m. This is a wildly unsuitable assignment for a horse of his profile, and I'm not interested.
Uzziah has been racing in Sydney Benchmark 78 grade and drops back to country level here. Scott Aspery's gelding ran fourth at Rosehill nineteen days ago, beaten just over two lengths, and before that ran second and third at Randwick. He's a seven-year-old with seven wins from thirty-seven starts, and he's shown enough in recent runs to suggest he's competitive at this level. But he's drawn barrier twelve, he's first-up into 1400m after racing at 1200m and 1300m, and I don't see where the speed comes from to give him the run he needs.
Indifference is a soft-track specialist with five wins from seventeen starts on rain-affected ground, including two wins from three on heavy tracks. Brett & Georgie Cavanough's gelding won at Armidale over this track and distance, and he's competitive at this level. But he's been racing in bush grade at Scone and Muswellbrook, and stepping up to a Benchmark 94 with Nick Palmer's 2kg claim feels like a bridge too far. I'd rather watch than back him at longer odds.
I'm leaning towards Voracious as the value play here. The market has overreacted to Hibiki Harmony's consistency and underestimated the Tamworth form. Iron Man is a legitimate chance if the race is run to suit, but I'm not taking short odds in a race with this many variables. If you're looking for a saver, Uzziah at longer odds could run into a place from his Sydney form, but I'm not confident enough to suggest him strongly. This is Voracious's race to win if the tempo falls his way.
The Benchmark 58: Local Knowledge and Fresh Gear
Set To Prophet has won twice at this track, both over 1400m, and he's racing at 1300m here after winning those races in soft and good conditions. Lea Selby's gelding ran fourth at Grafton seven days ago over 940m, then sixth at Tamworth over 1200m before those two Armidale wins. He's a seven-year-old with six wins from forty-nine starts, and he's been competitive at Benchmark 58 and 66 level throughout his career. Emily Farr's 2kg claim brings him to 59.5kg, and he's adding a blindfold for the first time. The gear change suggests they're trying to sharpen him up, and with his track record here, he's the logical favourite.
Love That Girl is lightly raced with just three starts, one win at this track over 1100m on soft ground, and she's adding blinkers for the first time. Stirling Osland's filly ran eleventh at Tamworth ten days ago in Class 1 grade, beaten sixteen lengths, which is a horror run. But before that, she won her maiden here on debut, and the blinkers could make a significant difference. She's drawn barrier sixteen, which is a concern, but Mikayla Weir is a strong rider and the 55.5kg weight is a genuine advantage. I'm not backing her at longer odds, but she's worth noting if the market drifts.
Denetta is a seven-year-old mare with three wins from thirty-three starts, and she's been racing in Queensland Benchmark 58 and 65 grade. Stephanie Sixtus's mare ran sixth at Warwick seventeen days ago, beaten nearly seven lengths, and before that ran seventh at Beaudesert and sixth at Kilcoy. She's a Denman mare who has won three times at 1300m, and she handles soft tracks with two wins from seventeen starts. But her recent form is unconvincing, and I don't see enough here to suggest she's competitive against this field.
Lord Of The Sun is short as a market favourite, and I'm not sure why. Sue Grills's gelding has won once at this track from four starts, and he ran fifth at Mudgee nineteen days ago in Benchmark 66 grade, beaten over two lengths. Before that, he ran fourth at Tamworth in Benchmark 58 grade, beaten less than two lengths, which is competitive form. But he's never raced at 1300m, he's drawn barrier four in a race with no speed, and I don't see where the winning run comes from. He's a consistent type who will be in the finish, but I'm not taking short odds on him.
Major Makeover returns from a 132-day spell and ran fourth at Moree last time out, beaten less than a length in Benchmark 58 grade. Craig Clegg's gelding has run second twice at this track over 1300m, and he's a consistent type who has placed at this level throughout his career. Andrew Mallyon is a strong booking, and the fresh-up record is solid with a win from three starts. I'd have him as a value play at longer odds, but the market has him mid-range and I'm not convinced he's fit enough to win first-up after such a long break.
I'm with Set To Prophet here, despite the gear change raising questions. His track record is too strong to ignore, and the blindfold could sharpen him up enough to make the difference. Love That Girl is the roughie if the blinkers work, but I'm not confident enough to suggest her strongly. This is Set To Prophet's race to lose.
The Newmarket: Favourites Under Pressure
Chandon Star is short as the market favourite, and I'm immediately sceptical. Jane Clement's gelding has won seven from thirty starts, and he ran second at Dubbo six days ago in Benchmark 82 grade, beaten over two lengths by Inazuma Boy. Before that, he ran second to the same horse at Tamworth, beaten a nose, then won at Tamworth in Benchmark 82 grade. He's a consistent performer who has won once from ten starts at 1100m, and he handles this track with six starts for no wins. His soft-track record is poor with no wins from nine starts, and while he's dropping from Benchmark 82 to open class, I don't see enough here to justify short odds. Chelsea Hillier's 3.5kg claim brings him to 57.5kg, which is a significant advantage, but I'm not convinced he's value.
Saratoga Power is the horse I want. Brett & Georgie Cavanough's gelding ran fourth at Muswellbrook four days ago in Benchmark 82 grade, beaten three and a half lengths, and before that ran fourth at Scone over 900m. But wind the clock back further and he won at Mudgee over 1200m on soft ground, then ran second at Muswellbrook over 1000m in open grade. He's a Written Tycoon gelding with seven wins from nineteen starts, and he's proven at this level. Nick Palmer's 2kg claim brings him to 58kg, and he's dropping from Benchmark 82 to open class, which is a significant drop. The concern is his record at 1100m with no wins from two starts, but his recent form suggests he's competitive here.
Bomarea is short in the market and I'm not sure why. Marc Quinn's mare ran third at Port Macquarie eighteen days ago, beaten less than two lengths, and before that ran third at Port Macquarie again over 1006m. She's a consistent mare who has won four times from nineteen starts, but her soft-track record is poor with one win from four starts, and she's never won at 1100m. She's adding blinkers again, which suggests they're trying to sharpen her up, but I don't see enough here to justify short odds.
Two Ya Got is a nine-time winner from thirty-five starts, and he's dropping from Benchmark 82 to open class. Brett & Georgie Cavanough's gelding ran tenth at Muswellbrook four days ago, beaten nearly seven lengths, which is a poor run. Before that, he ran eighth at Tamworth and eighth at Eagle Farm, which suggests he's out of form. He's a proven performer at 1100m with four wins from eleven starts, but his recent form is unconvincing and I'm not interested.
Rivkin is a wet-tracker with three wins from nine starts on heavy tracks, and he's competitive at this level. Lyle Chandler's gelding ran seventh at Tamworth seventeen days ago, beaten two and a half lengths, and before that ran second at Walcha over 1000m. He's a consistent type who handles soft tracks with two wins from eleven starts, and he's competitive at this level. But he's drawn barrier ten with no jockey booked, which is a concern, and I'd rather watch than back him.
I'm backing Saratoga Power as the value play here. The market has underestimated his recent form and overreacted to Chandon Star's consistency. Bomarea is a legitimate chance if the blinkers work, but I'm not taking short odds on a mare with her soft-track record. This is Saratoga Power's race to win if he brings his Mudgee form to Armidale.
The Sunshine Coast Stayers: Heavy Ground and Fresh Hopes
Let's Do It Again carries top weight after winning at Eagle Farm over 1845m in Class 1 grade, and he's stepping up to Class 2 here. Toby Edmonds's gelding ran fifth at Gold Coast nineteen days ago in Benchmark 68 grade, beaten just over two lengths, and before that ran third at Beaudesert over 1050m. He's a lightly raced gelding with two wins from ten starts, and he's proven at 1600m with a second placing from two starts. Bella Youngberry's 2kg claim brings him to 58kg, which is a significant advantage, and he's dropping from Benchmark 68 to Class 2. The concern is his record on heavy tracks, where he's untested, but this is only a Heavy 8 and he's proven on soft ground with one win from six starts.
Cool Running has won twice at this track, both over 1600m, and he's racing here again after running second at Ipswich fourteen days ago in Class 2 grade, beaten less than half a length. Michael Lakey's gelding won at this track over this distance on soft ground, and before that ran tenth at Eagle Farm in Class 1 grade. He's a consistent type who has won twice from thirteen starts, and he handles heavy ground with one win from one start. The concern is his overall record with just two wins from thirteen starts, but his track record here is strong and he's proven at this level.
More For Ready is short as a market favourite, and I don't understand why. Michael Morrison's mare ran second at Warwick seventeen days ago in Benchmark 65 grade, beaten just over two lengths, and before that ran sixth at Doomben in Benchmark 70 grade. She's a consistent mare who has won twice from seventeen starts, but her record at 1600m is untested and she's never won beyond 1350m. Brandon Lerena is a strong booking, but I'm not taking short odds on a mare stepping up in distance for the first time.
Fifty Calibre won his maiden at this track over 1600m on soft ground eighteen days ago, and he's stepping up to Class 2 here. Jack Bruce's gelding is lightly raced with one win from seven starts, and he's proven at 1600m with one win from three starts. He handles soft ground with one win from four starts, and he's proven on heavy ground with a second placing from one start. The concern is his class, stepping from maiden grade to Class 2, but his recent win suggests he's progressive enough to be competitive here.
Bit Of Grunt returns from a 19-day break and ran fourth at Doomben in Class 1 grade, beaten just over two lengths. Gary Duncan's gelding has run second three times at this track from thirteen starts, and he's a consistent type who has placed at this level throughout his career. He handles heavy ground with one win from four starts, and he's proven at 1600m with a second placing from four starts. The concern is his overall record with just one win from twenty-two starts, but he's a consistent type who will be in the finish.
I'm leaning towards Let's Do It Again as the value play here, despite carrying top weight. His Eagle Farm win was impressive, and the drop from Benchmark 68 to Class 2 is significant. Cool Running is the logical favourite based on his track record, but I'd rather take the value on Let's Do It Again at longer odds. Fifty Calibre is the roughie if he can handle the class rise, but I'm not confident enough to suggest him strongly. This is Let's Do It Again's race to win if he handles the heavy track.
The Stayers Cup: Distance Specialists and Tactical Questions
Goofinator is the horse I want in this staying test. Pat Murphy's gelding won at Warwick Farm eight days ago over 2110m in Benchmark 72 grade, and before that won at Canterbury over 1900m in Benchmark 64 grade. He's a proven stayer with five wins from twenty-six starts, and he handles soft tracks with three wins from ten starts. Dylan Gibbons is a strong booking, and the 60kg weight is manageable for a horse of his profile. The concern is the step up to 2400m, where he's only raced once for a second placing, but his recent form suggests he's progressive enough to handle the distance.
Dolce Dior is short as a market favourite after running second at Warwick Farm eight days ago, beaten less than half a length by Goofinator. Peter Snowden's mare won at Canberra over 1600m in Benchmark 60 grade, and before that won at Orange over 2100m in Class 1 grade by nearly six lengths. She's a lightly raced mare with three wins from fourteen starts, and she's proven at 2400m with one start for no win. Tom Sherry is a strong booking, and the 57.5kg weight is a significant advantage. The concern is her soft-track record with one win from four starts, and she's stepping up from Benchmark 72 to Benchmark 68, which is actually a class rise given the quality of this field.
Doradus ran second at Warwick Farm twenty-two days ago in Benchmark 72 grade, beaten two and a half lengths, and before that ran fourth at Canterbury in Benchmark 64 grade. John Thompson's gelding is a consistent stayer with two wins from eighteen starts, and he's proven at this track with two starts for a second placing. Chad Schofield is a strong booking, and the 57kg weight is a significant advantage. The concern is his record at 2400m, where he's never raced, and his soft-track record with no wins from four starts.
De Louviere ran third at Warwick Farm eight days ago, beaten less than a length, and before that ran fifth at Warwick Farm in Benchmark 72 grade. Matthew Smith's gelding won at Gosford over 2100m in Benchmark 64 grade, and he's a consistent stayer who handles soft tracks with two wins from ten starts. Kerrin McEvoy is a strong booking, and the 56kg weight is a significant advantage. The concern is his record at 2400m, where he's never raced, but his recent form suggests he's competitive at this level.
Mr Fabulous won at this track over this distance in Benchmark 64 grade, and he's stepping up to Benchmark 68 here. Theresa Bateup's gelding ran fifth at Warwick Farm eight days ago, beaten two and a half lengths, and he's a proven stayer at this track and distance. The concern is his soft-track record with no wins from six starts, and I'd rather watch than back him at longer odds.
I'm backing Goofinator as the value play here. His recent form is too strong to ignore, and the step up to 2400m shouldn't be a concern given his staying profile. Dolce Dior is the logical favourite, but I'd rather take the value on Goofinator at longer odds. De Louviere is the saver if you're looking for a place bet, but I'm not confident enough to suggest him strongly. This is Goofinator's race to win if he brings his Warwick Farm form to Kembla Grange.
Where I Stand
I'm strongest on Voracious in the Armidale Showcase Cup at ridiculous overs. The market has fallen in love with Iron Man and Hibiki Harmony, but the Tamworth form line is clear and the pace scenario suits Voracious perfectly. He's the value play in a race full of question marks.
Saratoga Power in the Newmarket is my second-best bet of the day. The market has overreacted to Chandon Star's consistency and underestimated the Mudgee form. I'm taking the value on a horse dropping from Benchmark 82 to open class with a strong recent record.
Goofinator in the Kembla Grange Stayers Cup is my staying play. His recent form is too strong to ignore, and I'm not taking short odds on Dolce Dior when she's stepping up from Benchmark 72 to face a field of this quality. Goofinator is the value play at longer odds.
Let's Do It Again in the Sunshine Coast Class 2 is my final strong opinion. He's dropping from Benchmark 68 to Class 2 after winning at Eagle Farm, and the 2kg claim brings him to a manageable weight. I'm taking the value on a progressive type who should handle the heavy track.


